Here’s your takeaway from the jobs report: The jobs market isn’t getting any worse. It isn’t getting any better either.
Nothing much changed in August for the nation’s work force, and nothing much has changed in the past year either. The Bureau of Labor Statistics reported 54,000 people lost their jobs in August, with 114,000 temporary Census Bureau workers coming to the end of that gig, while the private sector added 67,000 jobs.
Now, the stock market is reacting because the numbers were the proverbial “better than expected.” Consensus was for an overall slide of 110,000, with private sector adding 28,000 jobs. That’s all the market cares about, and seeing as it’s in rally mode anyway, it’s set to extend that rally.
This is such a middling report, it can probably be spun any way you’d want to spin it, so it’s best to try and look at the biggest picture possible. I’ll frame it this way: we’re eight months into 2010, and the economy has added a net total of 723,000 jobs. Job growth rose the first five months of the year, and has fallen the past three months. That averages out to 90,000 jobs a month, which is not even enough to keep up with population growth, forget starting to whittle down that 15 million-strong sea of unemployed people out there.
So this report is nothing to get all hot and bothered over, even though the stock market undoubtedly will.
There were some positives, let’s not kid ourselves. The revisions to July and June narrowed the losses in those months, which is a good thing. The number of people out of work for more than six months slipped to 42% from 45%; still a distressingly high number, but still a slight improvement.
However, the official unemployment rate edged up to 9.6%, and the broadest measure of unemployment, the U-6, rose to 16.7%. A year ago this time, the official rate was at 9.7% and the U-6 was at 16.8%, and haven’t changed dramatically during the entire time, so we’ve gone essentially nowhere in a year. If you believe the recession ended in July 2009, as so many do, then you’re talking about a year that was supposed to be a year of recovery for the economy. The jobs market didn’t get that memo.
“It will take many years before ‘full employment’ is re-attained,” Steven Wood of Insight Economics wrote. In August, there were 14.7M people unemployed (according to this table; in the actual release, BLS says it’s 14.9M); in August of 2009, there were 14.8M people unemployed.



